How to Reheat Bread and Butter Pudding?

To reheat bread and butter pudding, you will want to keep the dish tightly sealed. You can store it in an airtight container, plastic wrap, or freezer bag. If you’re storing the entire cake, you can wrap it in plastic to keep it from drying out, but this method will use a lot of plastic. The best container to use is compact and easy to work with. If the container has too much space, it will dry out quicker, resulting in a moldy pudding.

Bread and Butter Pudding

How to Reheat Bread and Butter Pudding

One dessert that can be readily reheated is bread and butter pudding, so you don’t have to worry about eating it all at once. Additionally, you can further extend the service life of your leftovers by freezing or refrigerating them.

The best method for reheating bread and butter pudding is in the oven, but if you’re pressed for time, a microwave will work fine.

Regardless of the way you select, we outline the procedures you must do below so you can repeatedly enjoy this delectable dessert:

In the Oven

When you serve bread and butter pudding, it will be excellent and moist because of the oven reheating. What you must do is as follows:

Take it out of the refrigerator or freezer.

If your bread and butter pudding has been kept in the refrigerator, take it out and let it sit at room temperature for about 30 minutes. Before reheating bread and butter pudding that has been frozen, it must first thaw.

Preheating the Oven Turn on the oven and warm it to 150C or 300F.

Get Bread and Butter Pudding ready.

Put the bread and butter pudding in an ovenproof dish that is the right size. Then, add milk or beaten eggs to the top of the dessert.


Place your bread and butter pudding in the middle of the oven with the foil covering it. 20 to 25 minutes should be spent baking it.

Enjoy and Serve

Upon reaching room temperature, top your bread and butter pudding with ice cream, custard, or pouring cream and dig in.

In the Microwave

The steps shown below can be used to reheat a little amount of bread and butter pudding in the microwave:

Get Bread and Butter Pudding ready.

Place your bread and butter pudding in a dish that can be heated in the microwave and top it with a little cream or milk. After that, please place it in the microwave while it is covered with a paper towel.


Reheat the bread and butter pudding for around two to three minutes on medium power. Check the pudding for doneness halfway through and re-microwave if necessary.

Enjoy and Serve

You’re ready to serve your bread and butter pudding with various toppings and sides once it’s hot off the stove.

What are the Three Tips for Reheating Bread and Butter Pudding?

Three suggestions for warming bread and butter pudding

Follow these three crucial recommendations for nearly-guaranteed success when reheating bread and butter pudding:

Only Once More

It would help if you didn’t reheat bread and butter pudding more than once. This is because repeated reheating of the bread will certainly cause it to deteriorate or get mushy. Consider portioning up your remaining bread and butter pudding after the initial baking so you can quickly reheat whatever much you require at any given time.

First, Defrost

You should thaw any remaining bread and butter pudding if you have frozen it. The pudding should be left out of the freezer and thaw overnight.

Include Additional Milk

The moisture levels are the most crucial factor when reheating bread and butter pudding. To keep it from drying, add a little extra milk to your dessert before warming it, whether in the oven or the microwave.


How to Make Bread and Butter Pudding At Home?


One tablespoon (55 grams) of room-temperature butter

Ten slices of diagonally cut soft white bread

1/2 cup (55 grams) of Golden sultanas or raisins

freshly grated nutmeg, 1/8 teaspoon

1/four teaspoons of cinnamon

1 1/2 cups (350 milliliters) milk

1/4 cup (50 milliliters) thick cream

two huge eggs (free-range)

One teaspoon of vanilla extract split among four tablespoons of white sugar


Assemble the components.

Toaster oven: 355 F/180 C. Use some butter to grease a 1.5-quart/1.5-liter dish.

Each triangle of bread was spread with the remaining butter on one side.

With the butter side up, arrange overlapping pieces of bread over the dish’s bottom. Spread half of the golden raisins evenly over the bread, followed by a little dusting of cinnamon and nutmeg. Repeat this layering process once or until the dish is full, culminating with the raisins on top.

The milk and cream should be heated slowly, not boiling. Place aside.

Beat the eggs with three tablespoons of sugar and vanilla essence in a medium heatproof bowl until they are fluffy and pale in color.

When all the milk has been added, whisk continually while slowly pouring the warm (not hot) milk over the eggs.

Until all the liquid has been added, slowly and evenly pour the egg mixture over the bread. Press the bread into the liquid with gentle pressure. Sprinkle the surface with the final tablespoon of sugar and leave for 30 minutes.

After 30 minutes, bake the pudding in the hot oven for 40 to 45 minutes, or until the top is golden brown, the pudding has risen well, and the eggs are set. Enjoy a hot serving.

What Is the Bread’s Shelf Life?

Several elements affect how long bread will keep before going bad. The shelf life of bread stored at room temperature is 3–7 days. The specifics depend on the components, bread type, and preservation method. Bread has a limited shelf life, yet it is still important to keep it properly. It should be kept at room temperature for the best results. Bread doesn’t require additional protection if you use it frequently. If the container is still sealed and unopened, you can keep it at room temperature.

If it’s overlooked, though, something will inevitably go wrong. Use bread boxes or plastic storage bags for sliced bread to prevent this. A traditional method of preserving bread, acidification is also one of the mechanisms used by sourdough to keep baked goods fresh longer. Adding 1% vinegar to the flour weight is a natural method for acidifying your dough and, consequently, your bread.

What Sets Bread Pudding Apart from Bread and Butter Pudding?

There are numerous recipes for bread pudding. The egg custard and cinnamon-nutmeg spices are present in all of them. However, they vary slightly from one another. There are identical bread and butter pudding recipes in the United States as in the United Kingdom. The main distinctions between British and American recipes are that British recipes butter the bread before soaking it in custard, add raisins or sultanas, and normally don’t top the dessert with a sweet sauce when serving. Instead of using larger pieces, many alternative bread pudding recipes employ cubed bread. However, none of these components are unique to bread and butter pudding from the United Kingdom.

How Do You Make Bread and Butter Pudding? What Kind of Bread Do You Use?

A loaf of bread that would otherwise be thrown away works best for bread pudding. After all, the origin of this dish lies in reducing food waste.

Some bread does, however, perform the task better than others. For illustration:

Sturdily constructed bread like brioche or French bread. Your bread must resist crumbling under the weight of the rich custard.

Sliced bread, not. Recipes frequently call for cubing the bread to specified sizes, which is difficult to do with pre-sliced bread.

French toast can be made using any bread. They pretty much have the same specifications!

Must Not be Used:

Too-stale bread is not good; slightly stale bread is ideal (see recipe notes), but bread that is so dried up that it falls apart when crushed, is so rock-solid that you can grind it into bread crumbs, or is otherwise impossible to tear by hand is not good. This is because it will turn into breadcrumbs after being soaked in the egg mixture;

Very hard, chewy artisan bread (like sourdough) won’t be as soft and custardy, but it will still work just well. Although the sourdough available at supermarkets and regular bakeries isn’t particularly crusty and will still work, I’m mostly talking about the more expensive (real) varieties.

Bread with seeds and savory flavors I’m not here to advise you on how to flavor your bread and butter pudding or how not to, but I will say that utilizing Cheese and Bacon Rolls can provide an unexpected outcome.

Naturally, heavy bread like dense ryes, pumpernickel, and the like.


To reheat bread and butter pudding, it’s important to ensure that it reaches a temperature of 165 degrees Fahrenheit before serving. This is the minimum temperature to reheat pudding for safe consumption. A simple cooking thermometer can help ensure this temperature. Otherwise, the pudding will dry out and lose its moist texture. However, if you plan on eating the pudding within a day, you should prepare it the day before.

The best time to reheat bread and butter pudding depends on your preference. Some people like their pudding cold and the best way to make it last longer is to freeze it. However, bread pudding defrosts very quickly. You can then reheat it later by placing it in the fridge overnight. If it’s going to be consumed within a day or two, the bread pudding should be refrigerated for a few hours.