How to Store Pumpkin Pie?

Eggs have been cooked in pumpkin pie, which often has a soft texture. As a result, bacteria and mold can grow there. Your pumpkin pie will often last for a day or two if you leave it out at the table before you start to smell something odd and notice mold developing on it.

Pumpkin pie can become soggy and unpleasant to eat if it is exposed to too much moisture, which is another enemy of the pie. As you can see, pumpkin pie is particularly susceptible to spoilage and needs to be preserved carefully.

Knowing how different storage techniques impact the final product’s quality is crucial if you’re wondering how to keep pumpkin pie fresh for a long time. Pie filling should be stored in the refrigerator at 40°F or lower because it contains dairy and eggs. The pie should be chilled to prevent the formation of bacteria that might cause food poisoning without changing the way it looks, smells, or tastes. Pumpkin pie will remain fresh for up to four days when properly stored.

How to Store Pumpkin Pie?

The best way to store pumpkin pie for later consumption is to put it in the refrigerator or freezer. Either of these can significantly increase your pumpkin pie’s shelf life.

Keep excess moisture away from the pumpkin pie or avoid condensation building up on the pie as another factor to take into account when preserving the pumpkin pie. The best defense against keeping your pumpkin pie moist in excess is to wrap it in plastic to make it airtight properly.

How to Store Pumpkin Piero, as you could have guessed, the first step is to air tighten the pumpkin pie’s seal before freezing it or refrigerating it.

Wrapping the Pie

If you don’t have plastic wrap on hand, you can also choose to wrap the pumpkin pie with wax paper or aluminum foil and seal it. When packaging pies for customers in a bakery, wax paper or plastic wrap works well.

  • Once the pie has cooled to room temperature, you can begin wrapping it in the material of your choice. Regardless of the wrap you are using, and you should abide by several rules.
  • Wrap the entire pie, including the baking pan.
  • Do not forget to seal it properly. Remember to lightly press the top so that it sticks and leaves no gaps so that the wrap touches the pie. As a result, the pie is shielded from the air.
  • If you are storing this at home, you can wrap the pie again for additional protection or put it inside an airtight container.
  • After completely wrapping your pumpkin pie, you can store it in the fridge or freeze it.

Putting Pumpkin Pie in the Refrigerator

It’s a good idea to preserve pumpkin pie in the refrigerator to keep it fresh for up to 4 days. This is also the simplest method of preserving pumpkin pie for later use. Before you start wrapping the pie, make sure it has thoroughly cooled.

Once it has been adequately wrapped, you can store it in your refrigerator’s cool storage area and remove it as needed. Check to see if it has been four days or fewer, and always smell the food to detect any abnormalities. It may have gone wrong if it smells awful, so you shouldn’t take a chance trying to consume it.

Let it sit for a while after taking it out of the fridge (if it’s still excellent), then carefully remove the wrap. If necessary, add the embellished components or some whipped cream at this time if you won’t be storing it again.

Putting the Pumpkin Pie in the Freezer

Consider freezing your pumpkin pie if you want to keep it for longer (around a week). The pumpkin pie should once again be wrapped adequately before being frozen.

However, keep in mind that freezing your pumpkin pie for an extended period may change your pie’s texture and consistency. For the most outstanding results, it is crucial to avoid keeping your pie in the freezer for an extended period. Instead, give it a half-day to thaw before reheating it briefly in the oven when you take it out. The pie may crack if you put it in the oven right away without first letting it defrost.

Necessary Precautions

The safety measures you need to take are as follows:

Cooling the Cake

You should wait for your pumpkin pie to cool completely before storing it to serve to visitors or friends who will be over later. It will be pretty hot when you remove it from the oven, making it challenging for you to wrap.

Condensation will build on the hot pumpkin pie when you attempt to place it in the refrigerator, ruining the filling and crust. As a result, it is advised to wait until the pie has reached room temperature, which should take 30 to 40 minutes. After the pie has thoroughly cooled, you can start wrapping it.

Applying Whipped Cream

Another thing to remember is that if you want to add whipped cream to your pumpkin pie to enhance its flavor, it is advised against doing so if you plan to store it in the refrigerator. It won’t just change the cream’s consistency; it will also be more challenging to package and store.

For the most satisfactory results, whip the cream just before serving.

Thawing Out Your Pumpkin Pie

You may be wondering at this point how to defrost pumpkin pie properly. Well, it’s a very hands-off phase and is relatively straightforward to perform!

I always make sure to take my pumpkin pie out of the freezer the day before I intend to eat it. I then clear space on a refrigerator shelf and allow it to sit. I’m done now!

Planning is crucial because your refrigerator will need to defrost for at least twelve hours. It will take significantly less time for the individual pie slices to defrost unless you’ve tried freezing them thoroughly.

You may easily spice up your pumpkin pie by baking some pie crust decorations or stuffing it with creamy Chantilly cream if you discover some flaws once the pie has fully defrosted.

Pumpkin pie has the beautiful property of tasting equally delicious warm from the oven as it does cold straight from the refrigerator. Remember that pumpkin pie can be frozen for up to three months and can be kept in the refrigerator for up to four days. The pumpkin pie will, however, always taste its finest if you eat it right away.

Reheating Pumpkin Pie

Would you like to reproduce the flavor of a freshly cooked pie? You may! The best results are obtained when reheating in an oven. Here are some short instructions on reheating pumpkin pie from the freezer and the refrigerator in the oven.

Pumpkin Pie Reheated from the Fridge

  • Set the oven to 300 °F.
  • Eliminate all plastic wrap.
  • Wrap the pie in aluminum foil.
  • Set in a baking pan.
  • Place in the oven for approximately 10 minutes or until the temperature is comfortable.

Pumpkin Pie from the Freezer Reheated

  • Set the oven to 350°F.
  • Place the pie on a baking sheet after removing it from the aluminum dish.
  • Bake for approximately 30 minutes, or until thoroughly heated

Microwave Pumpkin Pie Reheating

The quickest method for reheating pie is in the microwave, so use that if you’re in a hurry and don’t care about a crunchy, flaky crust.

  • Put a piece of pie on a plate that can go in the microwave.
  • Reheat for 30 seconds, then assess whether your temperature is right.
  • If not, add 10 seconds and keep going until the water is heated.

How Can You Tell if Pumpkin Pie is Bad Or Spoiled?

One of the best Christmas scents is the delicious aroma of pumpkin pie. The appearance of a freshly cooked pie on your kitchen counters, waiting to be devoured, is also pleasing. You might detect unpleasant odors because you are familiar with the delicious aroma of these scrumptious pies. To establish whether it is rotten, use the time limits mentioned above. Of course, you should discard anything with mold regardless of the situation.

How Long does Pumpkin Pie Last in the Fridge?

Homemade pumpkin pie will easily keep its freshness in the refrigerator for up to four days if it is loosely wrapped in plastic or aluminum foil. An adequately wrapped pie will still taste freshly made after two days in the refrigerator.

As with other things, the quality steadily deteriorates with time. On day three, you notice that the filling has a bland taste, and the crust is beginning to dry up. After four days, pumpkin pie is still safe to eat, but the crust will probably be a little bland and soggy on the bottom and dry around the edges.

How Can I Tell if My Pumpkin Pie is Still Fresh?

Although the average window for freshness is two to four days, if you have a strong dislike for food waste, you might be tempted to preserve your pie for a more extended Check it for any strange smells or discolored appearances, such as excessive weeping or separation; of course, any pies with mold should be thrown away.

Can I Freeze Pumpkin Pie?

Pumpkin pie may be frozen for up to a month if you want to get a head start on your holiday baking. (This is fantastic if you want to freeze extra pumpkin pie to eat a few weeks after Thanksgiving.) Bake your pie in a reusable aluminum foil pan for the best results. Because the pie may freeze more quickly in the thin pan, there is less likely that the filling will develop giant ice crystals, which can change the texture of your pie. Bonus: Using an aluminum pan, you may bake an apple or pecan pie on your glass or ceramic pie plate.

After baking, let the pie cool completely before wrapping it securely in three layers of plastic wrap and a layer of aluminum foil. Once frozen solid, store the pie in the freezer for up to a month.

After Preserving it, How Should I Serve Pumpkin Pie?

You have choices when it comes to providing pre-made pumpkin pie. Since many people prefer their pumpkin pie cold, it can be served straight from the refrigerator to the table after a quick stop for whipped cream. Take the pie out of the fridge to remove the chill before serving if you want room-temperature pie, but don’t leave it out for more than two hours. Ideally heated.

If you want to reheat a piece, several slices, or the entire pie, wrap it in foil loosely and bake it at 350 degrees Fahrenheit until cooked all the way through. Check by sliding a knife through the center; if the pie is warm throughout, the knife will feel warm to the touch. Depending on how much pie you’re warming, this process can take between 10 and 15 minutes. Pumpkin pie cannot be stored or refrigerated once it has been thawed.

Can Pumpkin Pie be Left Out Overnight?

Consider pumpkin pie more like a quiche than a fruit pie for preservation concerns since it is a custard made of eggs and milk. Do you ever leave cooked eggs outside all night? Not likely and certainly not recommended. The refrigerator is a pumpkin pie friend. Fortunately, pumpkin pie tastes delicious served cold, straight from the refrigerator.


Although pumpkin pie is a beautiful treat, it can occasionally be challenging to keep because it is so perishable. However, now that you’ve read our “how to store pumpkin pie” advice, you shouldn’t experience any issues. Diligence and awareness are required to ensure your pumpkin pie leftovers don’t go to waste.